“They had a fairly decent game but there are two players that are exactly what’s wrong with Man United” – This is according to Dimitar Berbatov as he praises two players who earn 8/10 for standout performances, while he criticizes a struggling duo rated 4/10 that nearly derail Amorim in tense Tottenham stalemate

Manchester United’s 2–2 draw with Tottenham Hotspur at Old Trafford has left fans divided, and former United striker Dimitar Berbatov has not held back in his assessment. While he applauded two players for their resilience and ledership, he was scathing about two others who he believes represent “exactly what’s wrong” with the current Manchester United side.

It was a night of drama and emotion as United, under Ruben Amorim, battled hard against a spirited Spurs team. Bryan Mbeumo opened the scoring with a brilliant header after a slick move involving Amad Diallo and Matheus Cunha. Despite a strong start, the Red Devils once again showed inconsistency, allowing Tottenham to claw their way back into the game through Mathys Tel before Richarlison appeared to steal victory late on. Matthijs De Ligt’s last-minute equalizer salvaged a point but failed to mask the deeper issues plaguing the team.

Berbatov, who knows the pressures of leading the line for Manchester United, praised the performances of Mbeumo and De Ligt, rating both 8/10 for their impact. “Mbeumo was electric,” Berbatov said. “He gave everything, his energy was unmatched, and his goal showed his instinct and hunger. As for De Ligt, he played like a leader — solid defensively, and then he steps up with a crucial goal when it mattered most.”

However, the Bulgarian legend’s tone shifted sharply when discussing two underperforming players. “They had a fairly decent game overall,” he said, “but there are two players who are exactly what’s wrong with this Manchester United side — inconsistent, careless, and lacking discipline.” Though he didn’t name them directly, reports suggest he was referring to Harry Maguire and Noussair Mazraoui, both of whom struggled defensively and failed to match the intensity required.

Maguire, returning to the starting lineup, was criticized for being too slow to react to Tottenham’s counterattacks, while Mazraoui’s positional lapses left gaps that Spurs repeatedly exploited. “These are experienced players,” Berbatov noted, “but experience means nothing if you can’t maintain focus. United can’t keep throwing away games because of basic errors.”

Amorim’s tactical adjustments showed promise, but the cracks in United’s defense were clear. Tottenham dominated large spells in the second half, forcing Senne Lammens into two crucial saves and exposing United’s fragility without the ball. “They looked disorganized the moment Spurs turned up the tempo,” one pundit remarked. “It’s like the same movie playing every week — moments of brilliance followed by lapses in concentration.”

Berbatov’s remarks echo a growing frustration among United supporters. Despite flashes of improvement under Amorim, the team remains a blend of brilliance and chaos — capable of breathtaking football one minute, and utter collapse the next. “There’s no shortage of talent,” Berbatov emphasized. “The problem is consistency. Until that changes, United will keep hovering between promise and disappointment.”

On the brighter side, Bryan Mbeumo’s performance was widely praised as one of his best in a United shirt. His link-up play, energy, and determination to press from the front gave Tottenham’s defenders a torrid evening. De Ligt’s goal also served as a reminder of the leadership qualities he brings to a backline that has often lacked confidence this season.

Still, questions linger about Amorim’s ability to fix United’s recurring defensive problems. His system demands discipline, communication, and intensity — three qualities United displayed only in flashes during the match. “You can’t win trophies playing like this,” Berbatov concluded. “United have the tools, but not the mentality yet.”

The draw leaves Manchester United stuck in mid-table, with pressure mounting on Amorim to deliver more consistent results. While the team showed fighting spirit to claw back a late equalizer, the fundamental issues remain glaringly obvious. Fans are beginning to lose patience with players who continue to repeat the same mistakes, especially when the likes of Mbeumo and De Ligt are setting higher standards.

For now, Amorim will need to find a way to reignite his team’s focus before their next fixture. As Berbatov put it, “A point is not a disaster — but if United keep playing with this lack of balance, the same problems will drag them down all season.”