Journalist Reveals Manchester United’s Response to Garnacho’s Controversial Instagram Post

Manchester United have opted for silence in the face of yet another controversy involving young winger Alejandro Garnacho. The Argentine’s recent Instagram post, which showed him wearing an Aston Villa jersey with teammate Marcus Rashford’s name on the back, has stirred unrest among the fanbase and added fuel to the growing uncertainty surrounding his future at Old Trafford.

Garnacho, currently on holiday, sparked outrage with a series of Instagram stories, but it was the Aston Villa shirt featuring Rashford’s name that raised the most eyebrows. Fans were quick to question the implications of the post — was it a cryptic message about Garnacho’s potential departure or Rashford’s uncertain standing under new boss Rúben Amorim?

To add intrigue, Rashford himself replied to the post with a brief but impactful message: “My brother ❤️.” That comment, though affectionate on the surface, deepened suspicions that both players might be preparing for life away from United. The club has endured a difficult transitional phase since Amorim replaced Erik ten Hag, and discipline, clarity, and ambition have become central to the Portuguese manager’s new regime.

Sources close to the club, particularly transfer insider Fabrizio Romano, have revealed that Manchester United have no intention of publicly addressing the Instagram post. In his newsletter for GIVEMESPORT, Romano noted: “No reaction, to be fair. Just a normal picture, that’s it.” It’s a message that seems calculated — United are choosing to avoid a media circus.

Garnacho’s situation is already precarious. Once hailed as the club’s next great winger, his stock has dropped significantly under Amorim, who reportedly no longer considers him untouchable. The 20-year-old’s Europa League final bust-up with the manager made headlines after Amorim allegedly told him, “You better pray that you can find a club to sign you.”

This confrontation wasn’t an isolated incident. Amorim’s tenure has been marked by bold and controversial decisions. He loaned out both Rashford and Antony, recalled Jadon Sancho, only to place all three — along with Garnacho — on the club’s transfer list. United’s strategy seems clear: clear out the old guard and problematic figures, and build a side that better reflects the coach’s tactical philosophy and values.

Despite the drama, Garnacho’s stats last season were far from poor. He featured in 58 matches and registered 21 goal contributions. Only Bruno Fernandes and Amad Diallo managed more for the club. Yet those numbers have not guaranteed him safety in Amorim’s vision for the future.

The Red Devils are already preparing a revamped frontline. They have completed the signing of Matheus Cunha from Wolverhampton Wanderers and are actively pursuing Bryan Mbeumo of Brentford, who has also reportedly turned down other Premier League suitors. A marquee striker is also being hunted as United gear up for a full-scale attacking transformation.

Internally, the Garnacho-Rashford situation is viewed as a distraction rather than a crisis. Amorim is said to believe in firm boundaries and wants players fully aligned with his project. Public gestures, even seemingly innocent ones on social media, are not being tolerated if they stir division or ambiguity.

The fact that Garnacho chose to wear a rival club’s jersey — even with Rashford’s name — felt like a breach of decorum to many supporters. Some fans speculated it was an intentional jab at Amorim or a sign of camaraderie with Rashford. Others questioned whether the post subtly hinted at the duo joining a new club together.

Former striker Troy Deeney went as far as calling for disciplinary action. In a fiery interview, he suggested that Fernandes should “smash” Garnacho in training to remind the youngster of the club’s values. While dramatic, Deeney’s comment reflects the growing sentiment that Garnacho’s attitude may be hindering his progress.

Even if United remain silent publicly, it’s evident that this summer will determine Garnacho’s fate. If he fails to mend his relationship with Amorim or attract sufficient interest from buyers, he could find himself in limbo — talented but untrusted.

The situation also adds to Rashford’s ongoing dilemma. After being loaned out, he remains without a clear future at the club he’s served for over a decade. While his relationship with Garnacho appears strong, his connection to Amorim’s project is tenuous at best.

As United fans wait for clarity, many are torn between sentimentality and the need for a fresh start. Garnacho represents potential, but also inconsistency. Rashford is a fan favorite, but has not hit top form in recent seasons. Amorim, meanwhile, remains steadfast in his decisions — even if they ruffle feathers.

This saga is more than just a social media post. It’s a window into a deeper shift happening at Manchester United — one where discipline, commitment, and alignment with the manager’s ideology may matter more than raw talent.

For now, the silence from the club may be strategic. But the noise surrounding Garnacho and Rashford is only growing louder. And unless their futures are resolved swiftly, it could overshadow United’s preparations for the 2025/26 season.