Journalist Reveals Manchester United’s Response to Garnacho’s Controversial Instagram Post

Manchester United have chosen a surprisingly calm stance after Alejandro Garnacho stirred up controversy with a recent Instagram post that featured him wearing an Aston Villa shirt with Marcus Rashford’s name and number. The post quickly caught fire among the United fanbase, many of whom saw it as insensitive and disrespectful, particularly given Garnacho’s uncertain future at Old Trafford.

The young winger, who is currently enjoying his offseason holiday, uploaded several photos on social media. One image stood out—a shot of him smiling while donning an Aston Villa kit bearing Rashford’s name. The timing of the post, coupled with recent rumors about dressing room unrest and Garnacho’s strained relationship with new manager Rúben Amorim, only heightened tensions.

Marcus Rashford’s reaction to the post didn’t help matters. The England international commented, “My brother ❤️,” under Garnacho’s post—an interaction that led to speculation about a potential show of solidarity, a farewell message, or even subtle defiance toward the club’s internal decisions.

Despite the firestorm online, well-respected journalist Fabrizio Romano has reported that Manchester United do not plan to issue any official comment or reprimand regarding the post. In his newsletter for GIVEMESPORT, Romano wrote: “No reaction, to be fair. Just a normal picture, that’s it.” That brief message effectively reveals the club’s strategy—ignore the noise and focus on internal priorities.

This relaxed stance may come as a shock to fans expecting a stern response, especially with Garnacho being one of the more polarizing young figures in United’s current squad. His immense talent is evident, but so too are the concerns about his discipline and fit within Amorim’s long-term vision for the team.

The Garnacho controversy is the latest in a string of delicate situations Manchester United have had to navigate under Amorim. Since his appointment, the Portuguese coach has not shied away from making big calls—loaning out Rashford and Antony, reinstating Jadon Sancho, and placing all three, along with Garnacho, on the transfer list.

Sources close to the club revealed that Garnacho’s relationship with Amorim deteriorated further during the Europa League final. The manager reportedly told Garnacho, “You better pray that you can find a club to sign you.” It was a damning comment that highlighted how far the player had fallen in the pecking order.

Statistically, Garnacho still enjoyed a productive season. He registered 21 goal contributions in 58 appearances, outperforming many of his teammates and proving his value when on form. Only Bruno Fernandes and Amad Diallo bettered him in direct goal involvement.

However, football isn’t just about stats—it’s also about chemistry, attitude, and adaptability. Amorim’s emphasis on tactical discipline and team cohesion appears to clash with Garnacho’s expressive and sometimes erratic style. The manager seems more interested in building around players like Matheus Cunha—recently signed from Wolves—and targeting reliable wide options like Bryan Mbeumo from Brentford.

With a summer clear-out already underway, it’s increasingly likely that both Garnacho and Rashford could leave Old Trafford before the new campaign begins. Their futures hang in the balance, and neither seems to fit the mold of the new Manchester United Amorim is crafting.

The club’s current silence doesn’t necessarily mean indifference—it may reflect a calculated decision to maintain transfer value, avoid further disruption, and prevent fueling media narratives. Romano’s insights indicate that behind the scenes, the club is calm but focused on reshaping the squad.

Many supporters remain divided. Some believe Garnacho’s youthful exuberance should be nurtured, while others think it’s time to move on from players who might not align with Amorim’s principles.

What’s clear is that this summer could mark the end of an era for several high-profile names. With Garnacho’s name constantly floating around in transfer whispers and Rashford already deemed surplus to requirements, the winds of change at Old Trafford are undeniable.

United fans can expect a very different team when the new season kicks off. Whether that’s a better or worse side remains to be seen—but what’s certain is that Amorim is not afraid to make bold, controversial decisions.

And if Garnacho is indeed on his way out, his final act in a United shirt may just be a social media post that symbolized everything about modern football: style, substance, and a touch of drama.