Is Alisson Becker, Liverpool’s Star Goalkeeper, Losing His Magic Touch?

Liverpool’s recent 1-1 draw against Nottingham Forest has left fans divided. For some, it was a hard-earned point against an in-form team pushing for a title charge. For others, it was another missed opportunity, marred by defensive frailties and an underwhelming first-half performance. Among the players under the microscope is Alisson Becker, Liverpool’s usually impervious shot-stopper, whose form has sparked a heated debate.

The Brazilian goalkeeper has long been considered one of the best in the world, but recent statistics paint a different picture. Since returning from injury, Alisson has conceded nine goals from just 16 shots on target in six Premier League matches. These numbers have raised eyebrows, with some fans questioning whether the 31-year-old is showing signs of decline.

Critics were quick to highlight Alisson’s role in Nottingham Forest’s equalizer at the City Ground, where Taiwo Awoniyi capitalized on Liverpool’s defensive disarray. Although the goal came from a well-taken shot, questions linger about whether Alisson could have done more to prevent it.

A closer examination of the goals Liverpool has conceded during Alisson’s return reveals a nuanced story. Several strikes have come from deflections, point-blank finishes, or situations where defenders left attackers unmarked. In such cases, even the world’s best goalkeepers would have struggled to make a save.

It’s also worth noting that Alisson has delivered stellar performances in high-stakes moments. His standout display in Liverpool’s Champions League clash last month reaffirmed his value, as he pulled off a string of remarkable saves to secure a vital win. These flashes of brilliance suggest his talent remains intact, even if the numbers hint at vulnerability.

Liverpool’s defensive issues extend far beyond Alisson. Injuries to key players such as Ibrahima Konaté and Joe Gomez have disrupted the team’s defensive stability. Meanwhile, full-backs Trent Alexander-Arnold and Andrew Robertson have been inconsistent, further exposing Liverpool’s backline.

Statistically, Liverpool’s defensive decline is evident. After recording seven clean sheets in their first 13 league games, the Reds have managed just one shutout in their last seven. However, context is crucial—Liverpool has still conceded fewer goals this season than almost any other Premier League side, with only Arsenal boasting a better record.

Expected goals (xG) metrics also provide clarity. Liverpool’s xG for chances conceded has remained stable since Alisson’s return, suggesting the goalkeeper’s recent struggles are partly due to opponents finishing chances more clinically. This perspective shifts some of the blame away from Alisson and highlights the broader defensive challenges the team faces.

Backup goalkeeper Caoimhin Kelleher’s performances during Alisson’s absence offer further insight. While Kelleher faced stronger opposition during his stint, Liverpool’s defensive record remained similar. This consistency underscores that the team’s issues are systemic rather than individual.

Despite the criticism, Liverpool’s goalkeeping situation is far from a crisis. Alisson remains an elite talent, and with Giorgi Mamardashvili set to join next summer, the club appears to be planning for the future while maintaining faith in their current number one.

The scrutiny surrounding Alisson reflects the high standards he has set throughout his Liverpool career. His ability to deliver in critical moments has earned him the unwavering trust of manager Arne Slot, who recently defended the Brazilian in a press conference. Slot emphasized that Alisson’s leadership and composure are invaluable to the squad, both on and off the pitch.

For Liverpool fans, the debate over Alisson’s form is emblematic of the team’s wider challenges this season. The Reds remain in contention for the Premier League title, but defensive lapses have made their path more difficult. Addressing these issues will require a collective effort, with Alisson playing a central role in restoring the team’s solidity.

Alisson’s critics must also remember that even the best goalkeepers endure rough patches. From David de Gea to Thibaut Courtois, many of Alisson’s peers have faced similar scrutiny, only to bounce back stronger. Given his track record, there’s every reason to believe he will do the same.

In the meantime, Liverpool supporters must balance their expectations with patience. The club’s defensive struggles are not the fault of a single player, and solving them will require tactical adjustments, better luck with injuries, and perhaps a splash in the transfer market.

Ultimately, Alisson Becker remains one of the best goalkeepers in world football. While his recent performances have prompted questions, they also serve as a reminder of the fine margins that define the Premier League. For Liverpool, the road ahead will be challenging, but with Alisson between the posts, they remain in capable hands.