Internally at Manchester United there is a feeling that moving on from Alejandro Garnacho could come back to bite them given his obvious potential. #MUFC

At Old Trafford, change is in the air. With new faces arriving in the boardroom and the dugout, Manchester United is once again reshaping its identity — one built on ambition, youth, and long-term planning. But amid all the excitement, there’s a quiet concern brewing behind the scenes: what if they let go of a star too soon?

That star is none other than Alejandro Garnacho, the Argentine winger who has thrilled fans with his daring runs, match-winning goals, and undeniable flair. While his name may not always dominate headlines like Marcus Rashford or Bruno Fernandes, internally, the club knows just how special he is — and just how risky it would be to move on from him.

Sources close to the club have revealed that there’s an increasing sense of hesitation regarding Garnacho’s future. Despite his occasional inconsistencies and recent frustrations, many at United believe that letting him go, especially at this stage of his development, could be a decision they deeply regret.

Garnacho’s journey at United has been meteoric. Signed from Atlético Madrid’s academy in 2020, he rose quickly through the ranks and captured attention with his dazzling solo goals in the youth setup. It didn’t take long before the first-team staff took notice.

By 2022, he was already making waves in the senior squad. His stunning last-minute winner against Fulham, his electric display against Leeds, and that fearless attitude in big matches signaled the arrival of a player with a unique blend of South American fire and European finesse.

And yet, his rise hasn’t been without bumps. With tactical shifts under Erik ten Hag, and now with Ruben Amorim reportedly preparing for a more disciplined and tactically rigid system, Garnacho’s raw style has occasionally clashed with managerial expectations.

Even so, his moments of brilliance remain unmatched among the club’s younger talents. Few players his age can boast of scoring in a Manchester derby or delivering against European opposition. It’s those flashes of genius that remind everyone at the club why they took a chance on him in the first place.

Internally, voices are split. Some see him as an untamed talent who still needs maturing — a player whose decision-making in the final third needs polish. But others argue that these are exactly the types of players United was built upon — unpredictable, bold, and fearless. Letting such a gem slip away could be reminiscent of other regrets in the club’s past.

The comparisons have already begun. Some insiders have likened Garnacho’s situation to that of Adnan Januzaj — another teenage prodigy who lit up Old Trafford in flashes before fading into obscurity. Others bring up Gerard Piqué, who left young only to become a Barcelona legend.

However, Garnacho’s ceiling appears far higher. He’s already proven his ability on some of the game’s biggest stages, and at just 20, time is firmly on his side.

There are also concerns about external interest. Clubs across Europe, especially in Spain and Italy, are monitoring his situation closely. Any indication that United might be willing to negotiate could spark a transfer race — and the club knows it.

But what hurts more internally is the thought of Garnacho thriving elsewhere. Imagine seeing him develop into a world-class winger, terrorizing defenses in the Champions League — but not in red. That’s the nightmare some insiders fear most.

It’s a delicate balancing act. On one hand, United must stay true to its philosophy of nurturing youth. On the other, there’s a need for results, structure, and cohesion. The question becomes: Can the club afford to be patient with Garnacho — or will they be forced into a decision they might soon regret?

For now, the player remains committed, focused, and determined to succeed at Manchester United. But whispers of doubt and transfer speculation can often grow louder, especially when not met with clarity from the top.

As the summer transfer window approaches, United’s decision-makers face a defining choice: double down on Garnacho’s promise or risk watching another future superstar shine for someone else.

And if they choose wrong, as some fear inside Carrington, it might come back to bite them in the years to come — painfully and publicly.

In a club that has always celebrated its academy stars, from George Best to Ryan Giggs to Marcus Rashford, Alejandro Garnacho could be the next in that long and glorious line. But only if United doesn’t let him go too soon.