Carvajal reveals the differences between Ancelotti and Xabi Alonso!

Real Madrid captain Dani Carvajal has lifted the lid on what it feels like to work under two very different managers — the legendary Carlo Ancelotti and the rising tactician Xabi Alonso. His comments provide fascinating insight into how the club has transitioned from one era to another, while also highlighting the early impact Alonso has made at the Bernabéu.

Since stepping into the dugout, Alonso has wasted little time in stamping his identity on the team. After guiding Real Madrid to the semi-finals of the Club World Cup, he kicked off the 2025/26 La Liga campaign with three wins from three matches. Those results not only placed Los Blancos joint-top of the table alongside Athletic Club, but also showcased a side playing with newfound intensity. Under his guidance, Real Madrid have allowed the fewest shots on goal and won more balls high up the pitch than any other side in the division.

Carvajal, one of the most experienced players in the squad, believes the shift was necessary. Speaking in an interview, he reflected: “Ancelotti is a Real Madrid legend and always will be. He gave us trophies, stability, and belief. But after so many years together, the cycle felt complete. Even Carletto himself understood that change was needed, and in the end, it has been beneficial for everyone.”

The right-back went further, contrasting the coaching philosophies of the two men. Ancelotti, known for his calmness and player-first approach, often gave the squad more freedom in terms of training schedules and on-pitch decisions. Carvajal admitted that this flexibility helped senior players thrive, but over time it may have lacked the sharp edge required to constantly refresh the team.

By contrast, Alonso has introduced a new discipline. “Each coach has their own methodology; they’re from different generations,” Carvajal explained. “With Carletto, we had more freedom and more relaxed timetables. Xabi is more direct, more demanding, and leaves nothing to chance. He is intense, but at the same time, very clear with his instructions. Everyone knows what is expected of them.”

That intensity has been visible in Madrid’s recent performances. The team presses higher, wins duels in dangerous areas, and shows greater tactical adaptability. According to Carvajal, this comes from Alonso’s willingness to adjust strategies depending on the opponent. “Football has been around a long time, but modern football demands adaptation. Xabi is not rigid — he tailors our preparation depending on the rival, and he gives us alternatives during matches. It makes us feel prepared for any scenario,” he said.

Beyond tactics, there is also an emotional dimension. Many in the squad, including Carvajal, share a deep bond with Alonso, having played alongside him during his days as a Madrid midfielder. That shared history has created an environment of respect and trust. Players know Alonso has lived the battles they are fighting now, and his authority carries extra weight because of it.

Carvajal also praised Alonso’s communication style. Unlike some managers who overwhelm their players with constant instructions, the Basque coach strikes a balance. “He doesn’t just demand — he explains why,” Carvajal noted. “When you understand the reasoning behind a decision, it is easier to buy into it. That clarity has united the dressing room.”

The differences between the two coaches also highlight Real Madrid’s evolving identity. Under Ancelotti, the team was renowned for its composure in big moments, often relying on individual brilliance to unlock games. Under Alonso, Madrid are beginning to show a more collective, system-driven style, without losing their star quality. This blend of discipline and creativity could prove vital as the season unfolds.

Still, Carvajal made sure to emphasize the gratitude the squad feels for Ancelotti. “We’ll never forget what Carletto gave us. He’s part of our history, part of our family. But football moves on, and we are excited about what’s ahead with Xabi,” the captain concluded.

As Real Madrid push forward with Alonso at the helm, Carvajal’s words underline a key truth: change, while difficult, can be necessary. The transition from one legend to a potential future legend has begun, and early signs suggest that Los Blancos may be entering a new golden chapter.