Is Alisson Becker, Liverpool’s Star Goalkeeper, Losing His Magic Touch?

Liverpool’s recent 1-1 draw against Nottingham Forest has triggered an intense debate among fans, with much of the focus on Alisson Becker. The Brazilian goalkeeper, widely regarded as one of the best in the world, has faced mounting scrutiny over his form since returning from injury. Is this a temporary dip, or are there deeper issues at play?

For the optimistic section of the fanbase, the draw was a hard-fought point against an in-form Nottingham Forest team that has transformed into serious contenders this season. Yet, for the pessimists, the match highlighted familiar issues—poor finishing and a failure to dominate defensively in critical moments. Alisson, who conceded from Forest’s first shot on target, has unfortunately become a focal point for this criticism.

The statistics since Alisson’s return from injury have added fuel to the fire. In six Premier League matches, the 31-year-old has conceded nine goals from just 16 shots on target. While these numbers are uncharacteristically high for a goalkeeper of his caliber, context is essential. Many of these goals were nearly impossible to save, stemming from defensive lapses, deflections, and well-placed finishes from opposition players.

Take Forest’s equalizer, for instance. While some fans believe Alisson could have done better, the strike was the result of Liverpool’s disorganized defense, which allowed Taiwo Awoniyi the space to capitalize. It’s clear that the problems lie not solely with Alisson but with a defensive unit struggling for cohesion.

Liverpool’s defensive frailty has been exacerbated by injuries to key players. Ibrahima Konaté and Joe Gomez, often pivotal in the backline, have missed significant game time, leaving gaps that even a world-class goalkeeper like Alisson cannot completely cover. In addition, full-backs Trent Alexander-Arnold and Andrew Robertson have been inconsistent, further exposing the team’s defensive vulnerabilities.

The decline in clean sheets is telling. Liverpool recorded seven shutouts in their first 13 league games, but that number has dropped to just one in their last seven. Even so, Liverpool’s overall defensive record this season remains strong, with only Arsenal conceding fewer goals. This contradiction highlights the complexity of analyzing Alisson’s performances—his struggles appear to be part of a broader systemic issue rather than an individual decline.

Expected goals (xG) data adds another layer to the conversation. Liverpool’s xG for chances conceded has remained stable since Alisson’s return, suggesting that opposition players have simply been more clinical in their finishing. This perspective shifts the narrative from blaming Alisson to acknowledging the ruthless efficiency of Liverpool’s opponents.

Alisson’s performances in European competitions, however, tell a different story. His heroic display in a recent Champions League match reminded fans why he is regarded as one of the best in the business. Pulling off a series of spectacular saves under pressure, Alisson showcased the composure and reflexes that have defined his career.

Caoimhin Kelleher, who deputized during Alisson’s injury, also offers context to the debate. The young Irish goalkeeper faced tougher opponents but produced similar results, indicating that Liverpool’s defensive challenges are systemic. The backline’s inconsistency, rather than Alisson’s form, appears to be the root cause of the Reds’ recent struggles.

Despite the criticism, Alisson remains a cornerstone of Liverpool’s title aspirations. Manager Arne Slot has publicly defended his goalkeeper, emphasizing his importance as a leader on and off the pitch. Slot’s faith in Alisson is a testament to the goalkeeper’s enduring quality and influence within the squad.

Liverpool’s transfer plans further highlight their confidence in Alisson. Giorgi Mamardashvili’s expected arrival next summer is seen as a long-term move rather than an immediate replacement. The club is clearly planning for the future while continuing to rely on Alisson’s proven abilities.

The debate surrounding Alisson reflects the high expectations that come with being Liverpool’s number one. Fans are used to his match-winning saves and unshakeable composure, so even the slightest dip in form becomes magnified. However, it’s worth remembering that even the best goalkeepers have rough patches—legends like Gianluigi Buffon and Manuel Neuer have faced similar scrutiny.

Critics often overlook the psychological toll of returning from injury. Goalkeeping is as much about confidence as it is about skill, and Alisson is no exception. With time, match fitness, and the return of key defenders, there’s every reason to believe he will regain his imperious form.

Liverpool’s title hopes hinge on addressing their defensive issues as a collective. While Alisson plays a central role, the team must also improve its overall organization and decision-making. The backline’s vulnerabilities, not Alisson’s supposed decline, are the real threat to their campaign.

In the end, Alisson Becker remains one of the finest goalkeepers in world football. His occasional misstep does not define him, nor does it overshadow his countless contributions to Liverpool’s success. As the season progresses, expect Alisson to silence his doubters and remind everyone why he’s still the heart of Liverpool’s defense.