Same old sh*t’: Man Utd fans make ONE demand after Arsenal score first goal

Manchester United’s opening Premier League clash against Arsenal at Old Trafford turned heated in just the 13th minute as the visitors drew first blood. Riccardo Calafiori’s goal from a set piece did more than just put the Gunners ahead — it ignited outrage among the United faithful, with most of the anger directed at stand-in goalkeeper Altay Bayindir.

The atmosphere inside Old Trafford, which had been buzzing with energy at kickoff, suddenly turned sour when Bayindir failed to impose himself inside his six-yard box. United’s defenders were caught off guard by Arsenal’s delivery, but many fans were quick to argue that their goalkeeper should have done far more to command the situation.

Bayindir, deputizing for the dropped Andre Onana, looked hesitant as the ball flew in, and that uncertainty allowed Calafiori to pounce. Supporters were quick to note the eerie similarity to goals United had conceded under David de Gea during his final seasons at the club — moments where the goalkeeper’s lack of authority invited chaos.

There were protests from United players, claiming Bayindir had been impeded during the buildup, particularly with William Saliba appearing to lean into the Turkish international. However, VAR swiftly dismissed the appeals, leaving United to restart from the center circle while Arsenal celebrated.

On social media, the verdict was merciless. Posts poured in within minutes, with phrases like “Bayindir not it” and “Same old sht”* trending among United fans. Some even went as far as saying the team’s goalkeeper problems had not been solved despite Onana’s signing last year, and that history was repeating itself.

The call for reinforcements grew louder as the game progressed. Fans argued that relying on Bayindir, who has had limited experience at this level, is a gamble United cannot afford, especially if Onana’s form or fitness remains inconsistent. With the transfer window still open, there were demands for the club to make an urgent move for a proven, commanding goalkeeper.

United’s defensive line, already under scrutiny after a shaky pre-season, came in for criticism too. Many supporters pointed out that while Bayindir’s indecisiveness was glaring, the marking in the box was equally poor. Arsenal’s runners found too much space, and Calafiori was gifted an opportunity that he simply could not refuse.

The frustration comes at a time when head coach Rúben Amorim is still searching for his best starting XI. Leaving summer signing Rasmus Hojlund on the bench, experimenting with Mason Mount in advanced roles, and juggling between Onana and Bayindir have all raised questions about stability in key areas. For fans, the goalkeeper situation is now the top priority.

Some even speculated whether United might regret not pushing harder for an elite goalkeeper earlier in the summer. With several experienced shot-stoppers moving across Europe, supporters argued that the club should have anticipated the need for depth, instead of relying on a backup who has not shown he can handle the pressure of matches at Old Trafford.

The early goal not only shifted momentum to Arsenal but also left United’s players visibly rattled. Every Arsenal attack that followed drew nervous reactions from the stands, with the home crowd seemingly unconvinced that Bayindir could keep them in the game. It was a psychological blow that United struggled to shake off in the first half.

Despite the negativity, some fans tried to look at the bigger picture. United had started brightly, pressing high and creating chances before conceding. The effort was there, but as one supporter commented online, “The goalkeeper has demoralized his colleagues.” Another added, “We were on top of Arsenal, but now every attack gives us high blood pressure.”

The debate over Bayindir will no doubt continue in the coming days, especially if Amorim refuses to reinstate Onana. What is clear, however, is that many United supporters are united in one demand: before the window closes, the club must act decisively to strengthen between the posts.

For a fanbase already accustomed to defensive lapses in recent seasons, conceding a soft goal to Arsenal in front of their own crowd felt like déjà vu. The chants of support that greeted kickoff were quickly replaced by groans of frustration — a reminder that for all United’s attacking promise, unresolved issues at the back still threaten to undo their progress.

And unless a solution arrives soon, the phrase ringing around Old Trafford and across social media — “Same old sht”* — could well define yet another seas