Manchester United shouldn’t even think of selling Alejandro Garnacho to Chelsea for less than £65m

The summer transfer window has seen plenty of surprises already, but one rumour that has captured the attention of fans is Chelsea’s reported interest in Alejandro Garnacho. The young Argentine winger is one of Manchester United’s brightest prospects, and many supporters believe the club should stand firm and demand top value if they are to even consider parting ways with him.

Garnacho, just 21, has quickly become a fan favourite at Old Trafford with his electric pace, fearless dribbling, and knack for producing big moments in crucial games. Since breaking into the first team, he has shown maturity beyond his years and an ability to influence matches — qualities that are rare in players so young. This makes him not just a promising talent, but a valuable asset in the present.

The talk of a move to Stamford Bridge comes amid a summer of major changes at United under Ruben Amorim. While the club has been active in the transfer market, bringing in key players like Benjamin Sesko, the potential loss of Garnacho would be a blow, both to the team’s attacking depth and to the morale of the supporters who have embraced his rise.

Chelsea’s interest is said to be serious, but many fans and pundits argue that any deal would need to reflect Garnacho’s true market value. A figure of at least £65 million has been floated as the minimum starting point, and for good reason. In today’s inflated transfer market, young wingers with Garnacho’s proven impact and future potential often fetch sums well above that mark.

The comparison with Chelsea’s recent transfer dealings only strengthens United’s bargaining position. Earlier this summer, the Blues sold Noni Madueke — a player who has yet to reach Garnacho’s level — to Arsenal for £52 million. If Madueke can command that price, it is only logical that Garnacho, who has outperformed him in both domestic and European competitions, should be valued significantly higher.

Moreover, Garnacho’s versatility adds to his worth. Capable of playing on either flank, he provides tactical flexibility for any manager, something Amorim has already begun to take advantage of. His ability to stretch defences, beat opponents one-on-one, and deliver decisive passes makes him a nightmare for defenders and a vital component of United’s forward line.

From a strategic standpoint, selling Garnacho to a direct Premier League rival like Chelsea carries an added layer of risk. Not only would United lose a player with world-class potential, but they would also be strengthening a competitor who is actively rebuilding to challenge for domestic and European honours. History has shown that such transfers often come back to haunt the selling club.

The financial side of the deal is equally important. If Chelsea truly want Garnacho, United must ensure they extract every penny of his value. That means a fee well above £65 million, potentially including performance-based add-ons and clauses that protect United’s long-term interests. Player swaps or discounts should be off the table unless they involve genuinely elite talent in return.

There is also the question of Garnacho’s own ambitions. While the lure of London and a new challenge might appeal to some, the young winger has often expressed his love for Manchester United and his desire to develop into one of the club’s key figures. For many fans, keeping him should be a priority, even if it means rejecting sizeable offers from elsewhere.

Ultimately, this is a defining moment for United’s transfer policy under Amorim. If they are to compete with the very best, they cannot afford to let go of their most promising players for anything less than their true worth. Chelsea may want Garnacho, but unless they are prepared to break the bank, Manchester United should hold their ground — and make it clear that their rising star is not available on the cheap.

For now, the ball is in Chelsea’s court. But one thing is certain: if Garnacho does leave Old Trafford, it must be on terms that reflect his status as one of the most exciting young players in the Premier League. Anything less would be a mistake United simply cannot afford to make.