‘Inconsistent and unreliable’: Fan urges Real Madrid cash in on two high-profile names

In a bold and polarizing statement, a Real Madrid fan has stirred up major debate across social media by calling for the club to part ways with two of its most high-profile Brazilian stars — Rodrygo and Vinícius Júnior. The post, which appeared on Reddit under the username Little-Leopard-8581, urged the club to cash in on the duo in order to finance a squad overhaul ahead of the 2025/26 season.

The user, who appears to be growing frustrated with the inconsistency of both players, argued that Rodrygo’s erratic performances and perceived lack of maturity make him more of a liability than an asset. “He’s inconsistent and unpredictable,” the post read. “One game he looks like a star, the next he disappears or gets caught up in unnecessary drama.”

The opinion didn’t stop there. The fan further criticized Vinícius Jr., suggesting that despite his immense talent, the Brazilian failed to step up during the critical second half of the 2024/25 campaign. “Yes, he’s incredibly talented — but let’s be honest, his form in the second half of the season was poor. Too often, he disappears in big moments,” they claimed.

Instead of continuing to rely on the current duo, the fan proposed a more radical strategy — using the substantial transfer fees both players would command to strengthen other areas of the squad. The suggestion included bringing in Manchester City’s Rodri to reinforce the midfield and launching an ambitious bid for Erling Haaland to lead the line. “That kind of investment could take us to another level,” the fan insisted.

This opinion quickly went viral, sparking intense debate among the Madridistas community. While some supported the idea of a shake-up, a majority of the comments across fan platforms — especially on Real Madrid-themed pages like Real Live — were staunchly opposed to the idea of selling either Rodrygo or Vinícius.

One fan, temidayo dj datt, summed up the sentiment of many when he said, “Don’t sell Vini, I repeat, don’t sell.” Another supporter, Kola Omolegan tayo, responded, “Some fans just don’t know anything, Vini is better in his position than any other Madrid player.”

Indeed, the emotional bond that many Real Madrid supporters have with Vinícius is strong. After all, the Brazilian played a key role in the club’s recent domestic and European successes. While his form may have dipped in the latter part of the season, his overall contribution — including clutch goals and match-winning moments — remains undeniable.

There were also emotional pleas from other fans pointing out that temporary slumps in form are normal, especially given the demanding schedule and injuries that plagued Madrid throughout the season. “Because Vinícius did not do well in the second half of the season, it doesn’t mean he is a bad player,” wrote Chike Obikwe. “He needs a manager that will brush him up — simple.”

Some fans even dismissed the original poster as not being a true Madridista at all. “This may be a Barcelona fan, not a real Madrid man,” ALLI MALIK commented, while Kalie Amin added, “All these are Barcelona fans… they think they can cripple Madrid.”

Still, not everyone was dismissive of the suggestion. A handful of supporters expressed support for a major squad reshuffle. One fan wrote: “Sell Vinícius? He is now like before again. Use the money to buy consistent players who will turn up in big matches.”

However, these voices were few and far between. A larger group emphasized that players like Vinícius are rare talents, not easily replaced. “Every match, Vini creates chances no footballer can,” Chigozie Opara posted. “Just organize him and let him finish better. DON’T SELL VINICIUS.”

As things stand, Real Madrid are already gearing up for a busy transfer window. With the confirmed signing of Dean Huijsen and a deal for Trent Alexander-Arnold reportedly imminent, the club does appear to be planning structural changes. However, there has been no credible report suggesting that the club is actively trying to offload either Rodrygo or Vinícius.

While fan opinions can sometimes influence narratives around players, it’s clear from the overwhelming reaction that Vinícius Jr. and Rodrygo still enjoy widespread support within the Real Madrid fanbase. In fact, many believe that, given a stable and injury-free squad, both players could explode in the coming season.

At the heart of this discussion lies a broader question facing Real Madrid this summer — should the club continue to trust in its current core, or is it time for a generational shift that prioritizes consistency over potential? With Kylian Mbappé expected to arrive and whispers of a Haaland pursuit lingering, the upcoming transfer window could indeed redefine the shape of Real Madrid’s frontline.

But for now, it seems the fanbase remains divided — with the majority leaning heavily in favor of patience, loyalty, and continued belief in the talents that helped bring Los Blancos back to the summit of European football.