Manchester City – Real Madrid: The Ratings of the Madrilenians

Real Madrid and Manchester City locked horns in a Champions League thriller at the Etihad Stadium, producing an electrifying encounter that saw the Spanish giants edge out the reigning European champions 3-2. The match had everything—brilliance, drama, and controversy—as both sides displayed the highest level of footballing quality. Erling Haaland opened the scoring for City, capitalizing on a defensive lapse, before Kylian Mbappé responded with an equalizer. The Norwegian struck again from the penalty spot, seemingly handing Pep Guardiola’s side control of the tie. However, Carlo Ancelotti’s substitutions proved decisive, with Brahim Diaz leveling before Jude Bellingham delivered a stunning late winner.

Thibaut Courtois: 7

Real Madrid’s Belgian wall once again demonstrated why he is regarded as one of the world’s finest goalkeepers. While he conceded twice—once from close range and another from the penalty spot—he made several crucial saves, especially in the first half, when City threatened to overwhelm Madrid. His composure under pressure and excellent distribution were vital in keeping his side in the contest.

Federico Valverde: 7.5

Deployed in an unfamiliar right-back role due to the absence of Lucas Vázquez, the Uruguayan dynamo delivered a performance full of heart and energy. He was tasked with containing the ever-dangerous Jack Grealish and did so admirably, using his pace and tenacity to neutralize the English winger. Going forward, he provided width and supported attacks well, showcasing his versatility.

Raul Asencio: 8

A surprise inclusion in the starting XI, the young Spaniard did not look out of place against a star-studded City attack. His composure in one-on-one duels, ability to read the game, and confidence in playing out from the back were all impressive. Facing Haaland is no small task, but Asencio stood his ground, making several key interceptions.

Aurélien Tchouameni: 6

The French midfielder was deployed in central defense, a position he has been tasked with before. While he contributed with some crucial interventions, his positioning was questionable on Haaland’s opening goal, allowing the Norwegian too much space. He improved as the game progressed, but his natural midfield instincts occasionally left gaps in defense.

Ferland Mendy: 5.5

A difficult night for the left-back, who struggled to cope with Phil Foden’s movement and Bernardo Silva’s quick feet. He was frequently caught out of position, and his lack of sharpness led to some nervy moments. Offensively, he was limited, failing to provide the usual attacking threat. A performance below his usual standards.

Eduardo Camavinga: 8

Returning from injury, the Frenchman was a breath of fresh air in Madrid’s midfield. His energy, ball-winning ability, and press resistance allowed Real Madrid to dictate play in crucial phases of the match. His relentless work rate helped disrupt City’s rhythm, and he was instrumental in launching counterattacks. A masterful display.

Dani Ceballos: 6

A quiet night for the Spanish midfielder, who struggled to impose himself against City’s relentless press. While he kept possession well at times, he lacked the cutting edge to influence the game significantly. His off-the-ball movement was good, but he failed to make a decisive impact.

Jude Bellingham: 7

The English sensation had a frustrating start, finding it difficult to impose himself due to City’s compact midfield. However, champions step up when it matters most, and Bellingham did exactly that. With seconds left on the clock, he arrived at the right moment to net Madrid’s winner, showing his clutch mentality once again.

Rodrygo: 6

Much was expected from the Brazilian, but he had an underwhelming night. His dribbles lacked their usual explosiveness, and he found it difficult to break through City’s well-structured defense. His work ethic was commendable, but he will need to step up in the return leg.

Vinicius Jr: 7

Madrid’s most dangerous attacking outlet, Vinicius kept City’s defense on their toes throughout the match. His blistering pace and dribbling caused problems, though his decision-making in the final third was inconsistent. However, his persistence paid off as he played a crucial role in setting up Bellingham’s winner.

Kylian Mbappé: 7

It was a tale of two halves for the French superstar. In the first, he struggled to break free from City’s defensive shackles, but after the break, he came alive. His equalizer was a reminder of his world-class ability, as he pounced on a rare defensive lapse. While not at his absolute best, his impact was undeniable.

Substitutes and Tactical Impact

Carlo Ancelotti’s substitutions turned the game in Madrid’s favor. The introduction of Brahim Diaz added a new dimension to their attack, and the Moroccan’s equalizer was the spark Madrid needed to push for the win. His energy and creativity troubled City’s defenders, proving the depth of Madrid’s squad.

Ancelotti’s Tactical Masterclass

Despite a rocky start, Ancelotti’s tactical adjustments played a crucial role in Madrid’s comeback. His decision to introduce fresh legs in attack shifted the momentum, and his trust in young players like Asencio paid off. Madrid’s ability to stay composed under pressure and take their chances at the right moment was a testament to the Italian’s experience.

City’s Missed Opportunities

Manchester City had their chances to kill the game but were ultimately punished for their inefficiency. Haaland’s brace wasn’t enough, and Guardiola’s side will be left frustrated by their inability to maintain control in the closing stages. The second leg at the Santiago Bernabéu promises to be an intense battle.

Looking Ahead to the Second Leg

With a 3-2 advantage, Real Madrid holds the upper hand heading into the return fixture. However, City will be determined to respond, knowing that they are more than capable of turning the tie around. The Bernabéu has seen countless dramatic nights, and another awaits in what promises to be an enthralling contest.

Real Madrid showcased their trademark resilience, proving once again why they are the kings of Europe. With Bellingham’s late winner setting the stage for a thrilling return leg, the battle between these two giants is far from over.