BREAKING NEWS ‼️: “Ruben is killing this guy’s career in the name of tactical experiment… His mates are now doing better than him” – Former Manchester City defender Kyle Walker says Man United has a player who’s better than Lamine Yamal but Ruben Amorim is killing him with a wrong tactical experiment.

Manchester United’s tactical approach under Ruben Amorim has been a major talking point this season, with many questioning his use of certain players. One of the most vocal critics is former Manchester City defender Kyle Walker, who has expressed deep concerns over how a particular United talent is being handled.

Walker, who has played against some of the best young players in the world, believes United possess a rising star who could outshine Barcelona’s Lamine Yamal, but his development is being stifled by Amorim’s tactical choices.

Walker’s Strong Criticism of Amorim’s System

Speaking in an interview, Walker did not hold back his frustration over what he sees as the mismanagement of a highly talented United youngster.

“Ruben is killing this guy’s career in the name of tactical experiment. His mates are now doing better than him. This boy has the potential to be even better than Lamine Yamal, but the way he is being used is just wrong,” Walker stated.

A Talent Being Wasted?

Although Walker did not directly name the player, many believe he was referring to Alejandro Garnacho, who has struggled for consistency under Amorim’s system. The young Argentine, once tipped to be United’s next superstar, has not been as influential as expected, leading to frustrations among fans and pundits alike.

Walker’s comparison to Lamine Yamal is significant. The Barcelona teenager has taken the football world by storm, producing standout performances despite his young age. Many feel that Garnacho has the ability to do the same but has been limited by tactical restrictions at United.

Tactical Experiments Gone Wrong?

Amorim’s tactics have drawn mixed reactions since his arrival. While his emphasis on pressing and possession-based football has led to improvements in certain areas, it has also restricted some attacking players who thrive in more direct systems.

Garnacho, known for his explosive dribbling and direct approach, appears to be one of the biggest casualties. Under Erik ten Hag, he was allowed more freedom to express himself, but Amorim’s system demands more defensive discipline and structured attacking patterns.

Why Walker’s Words Matter

Walker is not just any footballer; he has played at the highest level and understands what it takes to develop young players. His concerns suggest that United may be mismanaging a generational talent at a crucial stage of his career.

At 19, Garnacho is at a pivotal moment where proper coaching and tactical fit could define his future. If United continue using him in a system that doesn’t maximize his strengths, he could struggle to reach his full potential.

How Does Garnacho Compare to Yamal?

While Yamal has been excelling at Barcelona, Garnacho has found himself inconsistent at United. The difference? Tactical freedom.

• Yamal is allowed to roam freely, take on defenders, and create moments of magic.
• Garnacho, on the other hand, is expected to track back more and stay disciplined in a rigid tactical setup.

This contrast explains why one is flourishing while the other is struggling to make a similar impact.

Amorim’s Plan – A Long-Term Vision or a Short-Term Mistake?

To be fair to Ruben Amorim, he is still implementing his philosophy at United. Some of his tactical decisions may be aimed at developing Garnacho’s overall game rather than just his attacking instincts.

However, the concern is whether this approach is helping or hindering his natural talent. With players like Yamal shining on the biggest stage, Garnacho risks being left behind if his attacking qualities continue to be suppressed.

What Needs to Change?

For Garnacho to truly thrive at Manchester United, Amorim may need to adjust his system to allow more attacking freedom for wingers.

1️⃣ Let Garnacho express himself – Allow him to take risks in one-on-one situations like Yamal does.
2️⃣ Reduce defensive restrictions – While tracking back is important, forcing too much defensive work could take away from his offensive strengths.
3️⃣ Build the attack around him – If United believe he is a future superstar, they must develop a system that highlights his abilities rather than limits them.

Final Thoughts

Kyle Walker’s comments have sparked a debate about how Manchester United are handling their young stars. With Yamal making headlines in Spain, the question remains—will United unlock Garnacho’s full potential before it’s too late?

Amorim must decide whether his tactical experiments are truly beneficial or if he is unintentionally holding back one of United’s most exciting prospects.

🔴 What do you think? Is Garnacho being wasted at United? Drop your thoughts below! 👇👇