Is Alisson Becker, Liverpool’s Star Goalkeeper, Losing His Magic Touch?

Liverpool fans are divided over Alisson Becker’s current form following their dramatic draw against Nottingham Forest. While some supporters consider it a hard-earned point against a formidable opponent, others see it as another missed opportunity for victory. The match, played at the historically challenging City Ground, has reignited debates about Alisson’s reliability since returning from injury.

Alisson’s performance came under scrutiny after conceding Forest’s first effort on target. Despite only facing three shots during the match, the Brazilian goalkeeper’s inability to keep a clean sheet sparked concerns among fans. This is not the first time his performances have been questioned since his return, as his recent statistics reveal troubling patterns.

In six Premier League games since recovering from injury, Alisson has faced 16 shots on target, conceding nine goals. While the numbers may seem alarming, a deeper analysis reveals that many of these goals were challenging to save. Deflections, close-range finishes, and moments of poor defensive positioning contributed to the goals, making them less reflective of Alisson’s overall abilities.

Interestingly, Alisson’s recent Champions League outing showed glimpses of his brilliance. His reflex saves and command of the penalty area during that match reaffirmed why he is still considered one of the world’s best goalkeepers. However, his domestic form has raised questions about whether Liverpool’s defensive issues are undermining his performances.

Liverpool’s defensive struggles extend far beyond Alisson’s contributions. Injuries to key defenders like Ibrahima Konaté and Joe Gomez have disrupted the backline’s stability. Additionally, inconsistent performances from full-backs Trent Alexander-Arnold and Andy Robertson have left the team vulnerable to counterattacks. This lack of cohesion has placed undue pressure on Alisson to perform miracles between the sticks.

While Liverpool managed an impressive seven clean sheets in their first 13 Premier League matches, they have only kept one in their last seven outings. This decline in defensive solidity has raised alarms among fans and analysts alike. However, when viewed in the broader context, Liverpool’s defense remains relatively strong. With Arsenal being the only team to concede fewer goals this season, Liverpool’s title aspirations remain intact.

A closer look at expected goals (xG) data provides further clarity. Liverpool’s xG for chances conceded has remained consistent during Alisson’s return, suggesting that opposing teams have simply been more clinical in their finishing. This statistical perspective shifts some of the blame away from Alisson and highlights the randomness inherent in football results.

Backup goalkeeper Caoimhin Kelleher’s performances during Alisson’s absence also support this argument. Despite facing tougher opposition, Kelleher maintained similar defensive outcomes, further emphasizing that Liverpool’s defensive issues are a team-wide problem rather than an individual one.

Adding to the complexity of the situation is the anticipation surrounding Giorgi Mamardashvili’s arrival next summer. The highly-rated Georgian goalkeeper is set to join Liverpool, fueling speculation about whether he will challenge Alisson for the number one spot. While some fans see this as a necessary move for the future, others worry it may create unnecessary tension within the squad.

Despite these debates, Liverpool’s goalkeeping situation is unlikely to derail their title ambitions. Alisson remains a proven leader and shot-stopper, capable of game-changing performances. His experience and composure in high-pressure moments continue to be assets for the team, even during periods of inconsistency.

Fans’ reactions to Alisson’s form have been mixed. Some argue that the Brazilian has been unfairly scapegoated for the team’s broader issues. Others, however, believe that his recent performances highlight a decline in his reliability, prompting calls for a more competitive goalkeeping setup.

Liverpool manager Arne Slot has defended his goalkeeper, emphasizing the collective responsibility for defensive lapses. “Alisson is a world-class player who has saved us many times,” Slot said after the Forest match. “We need to be better as a team to support him. It’s not just about one player.”

This measured response from the manager has calmed some of the criticism but has not entirely quelled the concerns. With Liverpool competing on multiple fronts this season, every performance is under the microscope, and Alisson’s form will remain a topic of discussion as the campaign progresses.

As the Reds look ahead, addressing defensive vulnerabilities will be key to maintaining their title challenge. The January transfer window could provide an opportunity to strengthen the squad, particularly in defense and midfield. However, much will also depend on the team’s ability to regain the cohesion and discipline that defined their early-season success.

For now, Alisson Becker remains central to Liverpool’s plans. His resilience and professionalism will be crucial as the club navigates this challenging period. Whether he can fully silence his critics and reclaim his status as an untouchable figure at Anfield remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Liverpool’s journey this season will be as much about unity and adaptation as individual brilliance.

As supporters continue to debate Alisson’s form, the focus must shift to the bigger picture. Liverpool’s defensive struggles, injury setbacks, and tactical adjustments all play a role in shaping the team’s trajectory. Alisson, as one of the world’s premier goalkeepers, will undoubtedly rise to the challenge, proving once again why he is a cornerstone of this Liverpool side.